Performance:
- Original 65W Lenovo IdeaPad U310 MAG66GE AC Power Adapter Charger: This adapter is a higher wattage , designed specifically for laptop models. The higher wattage generally implies faster charging and a more robust power supply for the laptop.
- Original 170W Lenovo ThinkPad W520 4284-26U AC Adapter Charger: The HP Pavilion charger is rated low. It is suitable for a range of computer models, providing a standard power output for these laptops.
Compatibility:
- Original 65W Lenovo IdeaPad U310 MAG66GE AC Power Adapter Charger: Tailored specifically for the model, ensuring compatibility and proper power delivery for the laptop.
- Original 170W Lenovo ThinkPad W520 4284-26U AC Adapter Charger: Compatible with various models, offering a more general application across different Pavilion versions.
Design and Build:
- Original 65W Lenovo IdeaPad U310 MAG66GE AC Power Adapter Charger: Typically designed with Lenovo’s signature aesthetics and built to match the ThinkPad series in terms of design and quality.
- Original 170W Lenovo ThinkPad W520 4284-26U AC Adapter Charger: Crafted to meet the design standards of HP Pavilion series laptops, focusing on compatibility with these specific models.
Wattage and Charging Speed:
- Original 65W Lenovo IdeaPad U310 MAG66GE AC Power Adapter Charger: Offers a higher wattage, which usually translates to faster charging times and the ability to power a laptop under heavy loads more effectively.
- Original 170W Lenovo ThinkPad W520 4284-26U AC Adapter Charger: Lower wattage may result in a slightly slower charging time, especially under heavy usage or resource-intensive tasks.
Price and Value:
- Original 65W Lenovo IdeaPad U310 MAG66GE AC Power Adapter Charger: Due to the higher wattage and compatibility specificity, this adapter might be priced relatively higher.
- Original 170W Lenovo ThinkPad W520 4284-26U AC Adapter Charger: Being a general adapter for various Pavilion models, it might be priced at a standard rate compared to more specialized adapters.
Conclusion:
In summary, the choice between the two adapters largely depends on the specific laptop model and individual user needs. The Original 65W Lenovo IdeaPad U310 MAG66GE AC Power Adapter Charger offers higher wattage and a tailored design for laptops, providing a more powerful and efficient charging solution. On the other hand, the Original 170W Lenovo ThinkPad W520 4284-26U AC Adapter Charger caters to a broader range of Pavilion models but may offer a standard, yet less powerful, charging experience.